| Name | Census Frequency |
|---|---|
| William Plimbley | 25 |
| Elizabeth Plimbley | 19 |
| John Plimbley | 17 |
| Mary Plimbley | 16 |
| James Plimbley | 14 |
| Joseph Plimbley | 12 |
| Sarah Plimbley | 12 |
| George Plimbley | 11 |
| Annie Plimbley | 10 |
| Arthur Plimbley | 8 |
| Emma Plimbley | 8 |
| Henry Plimbley | 8 |
| Hannah Plimbley | 7 |
| Edith Plimbley | 5 |
| Ellen Plimbley | 4 |
| Emily Plimbley | 4 |
| Florence Plimbley | 4 |
| Frederick Plimbley | 4 |
| Ada Plimbley | 3 |
| Eliza Plimbley | 3 |
| Jane Plimbley | 3 |
| Richard Plimbley | 3 |
| Robert Plimbley | 3 |
| Thomas Plimbley | 3 |
| Timothy Plimbley | 3 |